Yeah, I had cleared it in NG no problem, but I think it was the last fight I did before I took an extended break from the game, and since you can't Sunbro there, I only ran it the one time. I keep ******** up my timing. I remember pulling the rats with a bow, killing one. Then I can bomb them with a Great Fireball and they should all be dead. Of course, while this is happening, I **** up my timing and the big rat jumps on me, I ***** up my recovery, and I'm dead the next hit. It's doable, and I'll get it.