so bolding the obvious:
"http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/threads/93517" wrote:
Since the Titan challenge will be going on throughout the coming days, we'll be doing our best to add the names of the winning Worlds below as quickly as we can. However, we appreciate your patience as the list won't be updated in real-time! Also, details on how to receive the cactuar earrings will be announced at a later time.
I saw my server listed as having the reward, logged in this morning and didn't see any new mail icon. triple check the post and then read the bold part.